📰 Murder Mystery Solved 12 Years Later 🕵️

Together With

Good morning, Cleveland! Did you know Machine Gun Kelly, Halle Berry, and Bigfoot are all from Cleveland? Okay, only two of those are true—but if Bigfoot was repping The Land, you’d hear it here first. 🏙️👟

Don’t keep us a secret: Share the email with friends (copy URL here)​

In today’s 216 Scoop Edition:

• Oh, Mother – make your reservations now

• Cavs drop Game 1 as three-point shooting goes cold

• Shocking murder mystery solved 12 years later, prosecutors claim

• Cinco de Mayo: Parties to make you say ‘Ole’

• The 216 Scoop Mother’s Day Brunch Guide

• The 216 Scoop Cinco de Mayo Guide

• W opens in Detroit-Shoreway

  
  
  John Petkovic & Victor Takakura

🎉 Advertise with Us! 🎉
Get your brand in front of over 25,000 highly engaged Clevelanders every single week! Whether it’s boosting your visibility or driving traffic to your events, we’ve got you covered. Let’s connect you with an audience that’s excited about what’s happening in the 216.
📩 Reply to this email to get started today!

IN THE NEWS

Oh, Mother — make your reservations now

It’s not like buying flowers and candy the night before. You’ll be hard-pressed to find a reservation for a Mother’s Day Brunch unless you get one soon – as in, now.

There are a variety of experiences at top restaurants across Cleveland, catering to diverse tastes with gourmet buffets, entertainment and unique dining settings.

But many of these restaurants emphasize reservations due to high demand, and some offer unique features like live music, floral arrangements, or scenic views to elevate the Mother’s Day experience.

Check out our guide in the 216 Rundown below.

SPONSORED BY PLUM TREE REALTY

🏡 Ready to sell, appraise, or invest in Northeast Ohio real estate?

Tyler Finkler, Realtor & Appraiser with Plum Tree Realty, offers expert local knowledge, better listings with pro HD photos, 3D tours, and floor plans—plus lower commissions that save you thousands. Whether you want a fast, fair cash offer or a detailed appraisal within 48 hours, Tyler’s streamlined process gets results with no upfront costs. Trusted by hundreds of homeowners every year.

📞 Schedule your free consultation today at 216-217-0223 or visit TylerFinkler.com to get started!

Cavs drop Game 1 as three-point shooting goes cold

The Pacers came in wanting to shut down the Cavs three-point shooting. Mission accomplished: The Cavs shot 23.7% on 38 shots from the distance.

Cleveland was out of rhythm and lethargic on both ends of the floor. They chased on defense and betrayed their principles, over-helping and rushing to the ball – and, in the process, leaving shooters open.

The Pacers high-paced offense took advantage by moving the ball and using Tyrese Halliburton as a facilitator. As we wrote in our preview, he is most efficient when he creates open shots for his teammates.

Halliburton scored 22 points, but more importantly notched 13 assists – resulting in Indiana shooting 52.8% on 36 shots.

The Pacers outscored the Cavs by 30 points from the perimeter. That’s the ballgame – a 121-112 lose in Game 1 of the series.

Cleveland still has the talent advantage. Going forward, it needs to adhere to its principles on offense and, more importantly, on defense — starting with Game 2, 7 p.m. Tuesday.

Shocking murder mystery solved 12 years later, prosecutors claim

For years, it was like an episode of ‘Only Murders in the Building.’ Podcasters would unravel the details in search of the killer in the shocking 2013 murder of Aliza Sherman.

The fertility nurse at the Cleveland Clinic was stabbed to death in broad daylight at Erieview Plaza while on her way to meet her divorce lawyer, Gregory Moore.

As it turned out, Sherman was led to the location until false pretenses: Moore had no intention of meeting her or seeing her messy divorce case go to trial.

He allegedly wanted her dead and either was, or conspired with, the ‘hooded figure dressed in black’ who murdered Sherman in 2013, according to a new Cuyahoga Country indictment that charges Gregory Moore with aggravated murder, murder, conspiracy and kidnapping.

“The Sherman family has waited over a decade for answers regarding their mother’s homicide,” Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Michael C. O’Malley said in a statement. “Through the tenacious work of multiple law enforcement agencies, evidence was accumulated that paints the unmistakable picture that Gregory Moore orchestrated and participated in the brutal murder of Aliza Sherman.”

The indictment spells out the motive, saying Moore did not want to start a trial on the divorce case, so he carried out the killing to make Sherman “unavailable.”

At various points, Moore even went so far as to call in bomb threats to shut down courts so the case wouldn’t be heard. In 2017, he pleaded guilty to making the threats and was sentenced to six months in prison.

Moore, 51, was taken into custody in Texas, and is set to appear before a Cuyahoga County judge May 16.

Cinco de Mayo: Parties that make you say ‘Ole’

Contrary to popular myth, Cinco de Mayo does not commemorate the day a gringo put a lime in a bottle of Corona and shouted, “Viva Mexico.”

But the holiday that marks the victory of the Mexican militia over the French army at the Battle of Puebla in 1862 has become a popular day to partake in Mexican-themed celebrations.

A number of bars and restaurants host music and food and drink specials that will make you say, ‘Ole.’ Check out the 216 Rundown for our Cinco de Mayo Guide.

IN PARTNERSHIP WITH COLUMBIA

Bundle up and save big! 🧗‍♀️ 🏃‍♂️

Columbia Sportswear is serving up an EXTRA 20% OFF already discounted styles with code EXTRA20. From fleece jackets to waterproof hikers, gear up for your next adventure without breaking the bank. Plus, members get $40 off orders over $200—just in time for spring hikes or your next chilly getaway. Whether you’re trail-trekking or just staying cozy, don’t miss this limited-time deal.

👉 Shop now and use code EXTRA20 at checkout.
Hurry—offer ends 5/11!

The 216 Rundown

The 216 Scoop Mother’s Day Brunch Guide

Table 45 at InterContinental Cleveland: Snazzy buffet featuring made-to-order dishes and chef specialties, including a made-to-order omelet station, a sushi bar, and a complimentary mimosa for adults. $40-$82. 10:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. Info.

Pickwick and Frolic on East Fourth: Wide-ranging spread features entrée-type offerings (salmon, chicken and rigatoni); meat carving, omelet, waffle and stations; salad bar, hot buffet and desserts. $25-$58. 11:30 a.m. to 6:30 p.m. Comedian Ms. Pat hits the Hilarities stage at 7 p.m. Info.

Sora: Signature breakfast and brunch items; a sushi station; entrée-like offerings (salmon, chicken & waffles, roasted pork belly); handcrafted cocktails; kid activities. 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. $15-$32. Info.

Fahrenheit: Four main stations feature: sushi; meats, cheeses, breads, fruits; a shrimp & oyster bar; carved meats. The “for the table” section features signature takes on sweet and savory breakfast and appetizer items. 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. $25-$65. Info.

Burntwood Tavern Brecksville: Cozy, rustic vibes; Bloody Marys and Mimosas; omelet, waffle and prime rib and ham carving stations; breakfast staples and eclectic lunch entrees. 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. $19-$42. Info.

Edwins: An eclectic mix of cold fish and salad items; carved meats; omelets, waffles and breakfast staples; and entrees (meat, fish, veggie, vegan). 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. $20-$60. Info.

Olesia’s Tavern of Richfield: Feels like a European Inn and features an eclectic take on Continental cuisine – whether its breakfast staples; Old World favorites; meat and fish entrees. 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. $31-$50. Info.

Brewdog: Breakfast staples, pastries and a complimentary drink for mom. 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. $15-$40. Info. 

Cleveland Botanical Garden: An all-you-can-eat brunch buffet amid the gardens, it boasts an omelet station, breakfast and lunch staples and a Mimosa/Bloody Mary Bar. 10:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. (Includes strolls in the garden.) $40-$70. Info.

Hofbräuhaus Cleveland: A Bavarian buffet with traditional breakfast staples – cold and hot: spaetzle, sauerkraut, red cabbage, wurst salad, brottzeiteller. Includes entrée-type items, including chicken paprikash and cabbage rolls. 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. $14.95-$42.95. Info.

The 216 Scoop Cinco de Mayo Guide

Barrio: The taco empire is celebrating its 13^th anniversary and Cinclo de Mayo with a new menu, margarita deals ($1 off, glass; $5 off, pitcher) and $2 off on BYO nachos. Times vary.

Don Ramon: The murals and décor say ole – and the fajitas and margaritas hit the spot. 11 a.m.-10 p.m.

Los Gallos Bedford: Spicy food, swell sangrias and the murals and cozy vibes make it feel like some faraway sipping post. 11 a.m.-10 p.m.

Around the Corner: The annual Cinco party is always a dirt-cheap hoot: $2 tacos, $4 Coronas/Modelos, and $10 Margaritas (plus you keep the glass). 3 p.m.-midnight.

Nuevo Modern Mexican: Annual Cinco patio party rolls out a pig roast, drink deals and Latin tunes. Noon-9 p.m.

Momocho: Is there a place with a wider selection of tequila in town? Check out the specialty margaritas, too. 4-9 p.m.

Blue Agave: Party-hearty vibes served with live music and drink deals. 11 a.m.-10 p.m.

CentroVilla25: Normally closed on Mondays, the Latino market and food hall opens  to celebrate the holiday as kiosk operators roll out fiesta menus. 8 a.m.-3 p.m.

The Local: The spot always goes hard and heavy. For Cinco, it rolls out Cuban jazz outfit Justo Saborit and Latin Nights – as well as a bunch of food and drink deals. 5-9 p.m.

El Palenque Brooklyn: The Mexican spot with the big drinks and plates rolls out a bash, 11 a.m. – 10 p.m.

Tapatias Taqueria: They party at this fun hang -- known for its street tacos, micheladas – starts at 3 p.m. with live music and margarita deals.

NOTES ON A COCKTAIL NAPKIN

Sports, Entertainment, & Culture

W opens in Detroit-Shoreway

The WNBA season starts May 16. The pre-season has already started– and Cleveland is reported set to get its own team in 2028. But there’s a place where you can already watch the league and other women’s sports.

The W Sports Bar has opened in the former Banter spot in Detroit-Shoreway.

The brainchild of Cassy Kopp and Ally Eclarin, (State Champs), and Shelley Pippin (Brewnuts) boasts multiple TVs and a mission: “The W Sports Bar is Cleveland’s first and only women’s sports bar, proudly 100% woman founded. We prioritize women’s sports and equality on our screens.”

The drink list rolls out themed, signature cocktails like “Root for Women,” “Of Course She Has a Drink” and “Beast, Beauty, Brains” to go with wines and beers an non-alcohol elixirs like the Soccer Mom.

The menu features bar-food staples – pretzels, pickle chips, mozzarella sticks, as well as flatbreads, salads and sandwiches.

VINTAGE CLEVELAND

Donovan Mitchell, Round 1, Game 1 of the 2024 NBA Playoffs on April 20, 2024 at Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse

Ooh and don’t forget! Tag @The216Scoop on Facebook & @216Scoop on Instagram to get your photos in the Scoop!

Extra Sprinkles

Your pet deserves the best—without the stress. 🐾 

EntirelyPets Pharmacy makes it easy to get FDA/EPA-approved meds delivered right to your door. From flea & tick protection to heartworm prevention and pain relief, we verify prescriptions with your vet and ship fast. 🐶🐱 Plus, enjoy 15% off with code EPX15! Trusted, licensed, and loved by pet parents nationwide. 🛒

Shop now at EntirelyPetsPharmacy.com and keep your furry friend feeling great!\

Feel the Vibe at House of Blues Cleveland! 🎤

From legendary live shows to soul-satisfying Southern eats, House of Blues Cleveland is where music, food, and unforgettable nights collide. Whether you're catching a headliner or discovering your new favorite band, the energy here is electric. Come for the music, stay for the experience—and don’t forget the mac & cheese. 🎶🔥

Grab your tickets now and let the good times roll!

WEATHER

Monday, May 5

59 🌡️ 46 | ☀️ | 5% | 💨 W 4 mph (3 knots)

Sunny with clear skies throughout the day.

Tuesday, May 6

68 🌡️ 50 | 🌤️ | 5% | 💨 WNW 6 mph (5 knots)

Partly cloudy with minimal chance of precipitation.

Wednesday, May 7

66 🌡️ 48 | ⛅ | 55% | 💨 W 7 mph (6 knots)

Partly sunny with scattered clouds and occasional rain showers.

_{Please note that weather conditions can change rapidly. For the most up-to-date information, consider checking a reliable local weather service.}

Live Shows in the 216

🎶 May 5 (Monday)

• iann dior – The Roxy | 7:00 PM

• Kevin Ford – Grog Shop | 8:00 PM

• Running On Empty – The Winchester | 8:00 PM

• The BellRays – Globe Iron | 8:00 PM

• The Black Jackets – The Winchester | 8:00 PM

• The Damned – Globe Iron | 7:00 PM

• Waterloo – The Treelawn | 8:00 PM

🎶 May 6 (Tuesday)

• Cab Ellis – Beachland Ballroom & Tavern | 8:00 PM

• Deathblow – Happy Dog | 9:00 PM

• Folie – Mahall's | 7:00 PM

• Food House – Food House Terrorizes America | 7:00 PM

• Fraxiom – Food House Terrorizes America | 7:00 PM

• Joe Brown – Grog Shop | 8:00 PM

• Pan Arcadia – Beachland Ballroom & Tavern | 8:00 PM

• Quarters of Change – Globe Iron | 7:00 PM

• Ryzan Music – Jack Lutz / Joe Brown / Ty Bogikes / Ryzan / Dakota Renteria with Hank Temple | 7:00 PM

• Sperm – Happy Dog | 9:00 PM

• The Burkharts – The Foundry | 7:00 PM

• The Ghost Club – The Foundry - Lakewood, OH | 7:00 PM

• The Wrecks – Globe Iron | 7:00 PM

🎶 May 7 (Wednesday)

• Ben Fuller Music – The Jesus Music Tour | 7:00 PM

• Blooms – Red Wagon Farm | 6:30 PM

• Cain – The Jesus Music Tour | 7:00 PM

• Caleb & John – The Jesus Music Tour | 7:00 PM

• Carl Verheyen – Carl Verheyen Band Live Recording Tour | 7:00 PM

• Cristina Vane – Globe Iron | 8:00 PM

• Dreadlock Dave – Private Event | 6:00 PM

• Flummox – Mac Sabbath 10th Anniversary | 7:00 PM

• George Clanton – The Roxy | 7:00 PM

• Gringo Star – Grog Shop | 7:30 PM

• Jon Reddick – The Chapel, Akron Campus | 7:00 PM

• Joseph O'Brien – The Jesus Music Tour | 7:00 PM

• Katy Nichole – The Jesus Music Tour | 7:00 PM

• Mac Sabbath – Mac Sabbath | 7:00 PM

• Pressing Strings – The G.A.R. Hall | 8:00 PM

• Savak – Cave | 7:00 PM

• Slater – George Clanton Live | 7:00 PM

• Steven Curtis Chapman – The Chapel, Akron Campus | 7:00 PM

• The Crane Wives – Globe Iron | 8:00 PM

• Thor Platter Band – Solo Acoustic at Treehouse | 6:00 PM

• Trauma Ray – Mahall's | 7:00 PM

The 216 Sports Area

Upcoming Games

Cavaliers

Home vs. Pacers, 7 p.m., Tuesday.

Guardians

Monday, May 5

Away vs. Washington Nationals, 6:45pm EST

Tuesday, May 6

Away vs. Washington Nationals, 6:45pm EST

Wednesday, May 7

Away vs. Washington Nationals, 12:05pm EST

Thanks for reading The 216 Scoop today. If you found something useful, please share it with someone who can explain every nuance of Cleveland history.

Watch this quick video (start at 0:50) to see how easy it is to add our app to your home screen!